Doctor Who: The Celestial Toymaker (1966)

UK, 2 April 1966-23 April 1966
4 episodes, average 25m
videotape, black and white, 4:3
mono, English
Previous Serial: The Ark (1966)
Next Serial: The Gunfighters (1966)
Series: Doctor Who (1963-1989) – series 3, episode 30-33

A British television science fiction serial directed by Bill Sellars. It was the first story to be produced by Innes Lloyd. Three of the four episodes are no longer thought to exist.

Premise

The TARDIS lands on a strange world ruled by The Celestial Toymaker. To escape with their lives The Doctor and his companions must successfully complete a series of sinister games. Steven and Dodo face a series of riddles and games laid down by The Toymaker’s assistants whilst The Doctor must complete the complex moves of the Toymaster’s Trilogic Game.

Credits

* = uncredited

Crew
Director: Bill Sellars
BBC
Producer: Innes Lloyd
Script: Brian Hayles, Donald Tosh
Script Editor: Gerry Davis
Studio Lighting: Frank Cresswell
Film Camera: Tony Leggo
Film Editor: Bob Rymer
Title Music: Ron Grainer with the BBC Radiophonic Workshop
Title Music Arranged by: Delia Derbyshire *
Incidental Music: Dudley Simpson
Studio Sound: Alan Fogg
Special Sound: Brian Hodgson
Costumes: Daphne Dare
Make-up: Sonia Markham
Designer: John Wood
Production Assistant: Snowy White *
Assistant Floor Manager: Elisabeth Dunbar *
Choreography: Tutte Lemkow *

Cast
The Celestial Toyroom
William Hartnell (Dr Who)
Peter Purves (Steven)
Jackie Lane (Dodo)
Michael Gough (Toymaker)
Campbell Singer (Joey)
Carmen Silvera (Clara)

The Hall of Dolls
William Hartnell (Dr Who)
Peter Purves (Steven)
Jackie Lane (Dodo)
Michael Gough (Toymaker)
Campbell Singer (King of Hearts)
Carmen Silvera (Queen of Hearts)
Peter Stephens (Knave of Hearts)
Reg Lever (Joker)

The Dancing Floor
William Hartnell (Dr Who)
Peter Purves (Steven)
Jackie Lane (Dodo)
Michael Gough (Toymaker)
Beryl Braham, Ann Harrison, Delia Lindon (dancers)
Campbell Singer (Sergeant Rugg)
Carmen Silvera (Mrs Wiggs)
Peter Stephens (kitchen boy)

The Final Test
William Hartnell (Dr Who)
Peter Purves (Steven)
Jackie Lane (Dodo)
Michael Gough (Toymaker)
Peter Stephens (Cyril)

Episodes

1. The Celestial Toyroom (2 April 1966)
2. The Hall of Dolls (9 April 1966)
3. The Dancing Floor (16 April 1966)
4. The Final Test (23 April 1966)

Alternative Titles

Dr Who & the Trilogic Game – early title
The Toymaker – early title
The Trilogic Game – early title

Extracts included in
The Doctor’s Composer: Dudley Simpson: Part One 1964-69 (2009)

Production Notes

Brian Hayles would write many Doctor Who stories and is best remembered for creating the Martian Ice Warriors and the planet and civilisation of Peladon. But his first pass at writing a script for the programme wasn’t so successful. In early 1965 he submitted a story outline titled The Dark Planet which was rejected by the production office. He came up with another idea, a fanciful notion of an alien toymaker from another dimension that faired much better – given the nod by story editor Donald Tosh and producer John Wiles, he was commissioned to develop the treatment as a series of scripts, the going by the simple title The Toymaker. Hayles originally envisaged the alien menace as another Time Lord, though this idea was eventually played down to the point where it barely registers at all.

Tosh came up with the idea of The Doctor and The Toymaker locking intellectual horns over a round of The Trilogic Game, which was briefly considered as the title for the serial, though it eventually became The Celestial Toymaker by the time Hayles handed in his completed scripts. Unfortunately, when Wiles and Tosh saw what he’d come up with, they started to worry about the number of special effects needed, many of which would be unachievable on the budget they had. A rewrite was called for, but Hayles had started work on United! (1965-1967), a twice weekly drama about a second division football team that he’d co-created with Anthony Cornish (many Doctor Who writers and directors would work on the series) and was unable to spare the time to do the new versions. Tosh decided to rewrite them himself, though Hayles would retain his writing credit.

Meanwhile, Tosh and Wiles saw the fairy story-like setting as a way to solve what they saw as a problem. William Hartnell was becoming increasingly frail, and he and Wiles had failed to hit it off, so tentative plans were laid to use the uniqueness of the story’s setting as a way to replace him, having The Doctor turn invisible for a couple of episodes before reappearing played by a new actor in the final moments of the last episode leaving audiences on a cliffhanger. The higher-ups at the BBC were having of it however and vetoed the plan, leading to Wiles’ decision to leave Doctor Who in early January 1966. Having completed his rewrites of The Celestial Toymaker, Tosh also decide that the time had come to move on and set off for a delayed honeymoon in mid-January, and Innes Lloyd took over as producer in February with Gerry Davis becoming script editor shortly thereafter.

Lloyd and the serials assigned director Bill Sellars soon ran into his first problem – two characters named George and Margaret, who would be seen playing games with companions Steven and Dido. Hayles had taken the names from the play George and Margaret written in 1937 by Gerald Savory, now the Head of Serials at the BBC. The story revolved around the imminent arrival of the two characters but they never actually turn up and Hayles thought it would be fun to actually have a George and Margaret on screen in Doctor Who. Savory initially agreed to the idea, but with the start of production just a month away, he changed his mind and asked for the characters to be cut from the scripts.

But Campbell Singer and Carmen Silvera had already been cast in the roles and with Hayles and Tosh now too busy to work further on the scripts, Davis was told to do whatever was needed to make the scripts work. He hit on the idea of retaining Singer and Silvera and casting them as various couples encountered in The Toymaker’s realm, including a pair of clowns, the King and Queen of Hearts, and pantomime characters Sergeant Rugg and Mrs Wiggs, giving them a third character played by Peter Stephens – the Knave of Hearts, a Kitchen Boy and the Billy Bunter-like schoolboy Cyril. These and other changes made to make Steven and Dodo more prominent and to save on the budget (previous story The Ark went significantly over budget) dismayed Wiles and Tosh who objected loudly to the alterations.

But it was too late now, and filming began on 2 March 1966 where the Trilogic Game was shot at the BBC Television Film Studios in Ealing, London. Recording on the main episode began on 18 March and continued on subsequent Fridays at the Riverside Studio 1 in Hammersmith. New material was shot for the images that appeared in The Toymaker’s “Memory Window,” but also flashbacks to earlier adventures appeared, marking the first use in Doctor Who of older footage (episode recaps aside), specifically scenes from The Daleks’ Master Plan (1965-1966) and The Massacre of St Bartholomew’s Eve (1966). Problems continued to dog the production. William Hartnell went on holiday for two weeks (hence that idea of him turning invisible), leaving The Doctor largely absent from the middle of the serial and the character of Cyril annoyed the estate of author Frank Richards, who had created Billy Bunter in 1908. They wrote to the BBC following the broadcast of the third episode to complain that Billy would never be as cruel as Cyril and their mood can hardly have been helped by an ad lib by actor Stephens in which he notes that although his name is Cyril, his schoolfriends call him “Billy”. At the start of the next episode, a BBC continuity announcer reassured viewers that Cyril was merely “Bunter-like”.

Audiences didn’t react well to the serial. The BBC’s Audience Research Report stated that “over a third” of them “actually disliked it” with some of them dismissed it as “ridiculous rubbish.” Subsequent generations of viewers were denied the chance to make up their own minds about the serial as all four episodes of the serial were wiped by the BBC, though audio recordings and production stills survive (no “tele-snaps” were taken for this serial). In 1985, The Australian Broadcasting Corporation were conducting an audit of its film archive and found a 16mm film print of the final episode, The Final Test. In 2023, The Toymaker, now played by Neil Patrick Harris, appeared in The Giggle, the third episode in the 60th anniversary specials and early the following year, an animated version of The Celestial Toymaker story using the original soundtrack, was released on DVD and blu-ray.

References

Periodicals

  • Doctor Who Magazine no.196 (17 February 1993) – illustrated article (Archive: The Celestial Toymaker by Andrew Pixley)
  • Doctor Who Magazine Special Edition no.7 (12 May 2004) pp.59-63; 74-75 – illustrated article (The times they are a-changin’… by Andrew Pixley; illustrated article (Wind me up (Let me go) by Michael Stevens)

Books

  • Doctor Who: The Complete History no.7 (2018) – illustrated article (Story 24: The Celestial Toymaker)
  • Doctor Who: The Handbook: The First Doctor by David J Howe, Mark Stammers and Stephen James Walker
  • Doctor Who: The Sixties by David J Howe, Mark Stammers and Stephen James Walker
  • Doctor Who: The Television Companion by David J. Howe and Stephen James Walker pp.85-88 – credits, synopsis, review